Should I Repair or Replace My Storm Damaged Fence?

Storms can cause a wide range of damages to your fence, depending on the severity of the storm and the type of fence you have you might either need to repair or replace your storm damaged fence. Here are some common damages that can occur.

Types of Fence Damage

There are several types of damage that your fence can sustain during a storm. Some of the most common types of fence damage include:

  1. Bent or broken posts: Fence posts can become bent or broken due to high winds or falling debris.
  2. Loose or missing boards: Heavy rain and strong winds can cause fence boards to loosen or even be completely removed.
  3. Leaning fence: High winds can cause the fence to lean to one side, making it unstable and insecure.
  4. Cracked or broken panels: Hail and flying debris can cause cracks or even break fence panels.
  5. Damaged gate: Gates can become misaligned, bent or even completely broken due to high winds or falling debris.


Signs of Fence Damage

It is not always easy to see fence damage immediately after a storm, but there are some signs to look out for. Some of the most common signs of fence damage include:

  1. Leaning fence: If your fence is leaning, it is a sign that it has sustained damage and is unstable.
  2. Cracked or broken panels: Check your fence panels for cracks or breaks. If you notice any, it is a sign that the fence has sustained significant damage.
  3. Missing or loose boards: If there are missing or loose boards on your fence, it is a sign that the fence has been damaged.
  4. Holes or punctures: Hail and flying debris can cause holes or punctures in your fence. These are signs of significant damage.


How to Assess the Extent of the Damage

Once you have identified signs of damage to your fence, the next step is to assess the extent of the damage. Here are some steps you can take to assess the damage:

  1. Check the entire fence: Walk around the perimeter of your property and check the entire fence line. Look for signs of damage, such as broken or missing boards, leaning fence, and damaged gate.
  2. Check the posts: Inspect each post for damage. If any of the posts are leaning or have visible damage, it is a sign that the fence has been compromised.
  3. Check the panels: Inspect each panel for cracks, breaks, or any other signs of damage.
  4. Check the gate: Check the gate for damage. Make sure it opens and closes properly and that the latch is secure.


When to Call a Professional

If the damage to your fence is extensive or if you are unsure about how to repair it, it is best to call a professional. A local fence repair company can assess the damage, provide you with an estimate, and recommend the best course of action. Attempting to repair the fence yourself can be dangerous and can cause further damage to the fence. Professionals have the experience and tools necessary to repair your fence safely and effectively.


Fence Repair vs. Replacement

Before deciding whether to repair or replace your storm damaged fence, there are a few factors to consider. These include:

  1. Extent of Damage: The first thing to consider is the extent of the damage. If the damage is minor and localized, a repair may be sufficient. However, if the damage is extensive and affects the structural integrity of the fence, a replacement may be necessary.
  2. Age of Fence: The age of your fence is another factor to consider. If your fence is relatively new, a repair may be the best option. However, if your fence is old and has already undergone repairs in the past, it may be more cost-effective to replace it.
  3. Cost: Cost is always a consideration when it comes to repairs or replacements. While repairing your fence may be cheaper in the short term, a replacement may be a better long-term investment if the damage is extensive or if the fence is old.
  4. Aesthetic Appeal: If the damage is mostly cosmetic, you may want to consider a repair. However, if you’re looking to upgrade the look of your property or if the damage is affecting the overall aesthetic appeal of your fence, a replacement may be the better option.


Pros and Cons of Repairing a Damaged Fence

Repairing a damaged fence can be a cost-effective solution in some cases. Here are the pros and cons of repairing your fence:


  1. Cost-effective: In most cases, repairing your fence will be less expensive than replacing it.
  2. Quick Fix: Repairing a damaged fence is often a quick fix that can be completed in a matter of hours.
  3. Preservation of Existing Materials: Repairing your fence allows you to preserve the existing materials, which may be important if your fence has historical or sentimental value.


  1. Limited Lifespan: Repairing your fence may only provide a temporary solution, and you may need to make additional repairs in the future.
  2. Aesthetic Issues: Repairing a damaged fence may not restore the fence to its original appearance, which can be a concern if the damage is visible or affects the overall aesthetic appeal of your property.
  3. Structural Issues: If the damage is extensive and affects the structural integrity of your fence, repairing it may not be enough to ensure its safety.

Replacing a storm damaged fence is often a more costly and time-consuming option than repairing it, but it may be necessary in some cases. Here are some pros and cons to consider when deciding whether to replace a damaged fence:


  1. Increased longevity: A new fence will likely last longer than a repaired fence, especially if the damage was extensive or the original fence was already old.
  2. Improved appearance: A new fence can improve the look of your property, especially if the old fence was unsightly or damaged.
  3. Increased property value: A new fence can increase the value of your property, especially if it is well-designed and built with high-quality materials.
  4. Customizable: When replacing a fence, you have the option to customize it to your preferences and needs, such as choosing the style, height, and material.
  5. Better warranty: If you opt for a professional fence installation, you may receive a warranty that covers defects in materials or workmanship.


  1. Higher cost: Replacing a fence is generally more expensive than repairing it, especially if the fence is large or made of high-quality materials.
  2. More time-consuming: Replacing a fence can be a time-consuming process, especially if you opt for a custom design or need to obtain permits.
  3. Disruption to your property: Replacing a fence can cause disruption to your property, such as digging up the ground and removing the old fence, which may be an inconvenience to you and your neighbors.
  4. Environmental impact: Replacing a fence can have an environmental impact, as it may involve the disposal of the old fence and the use of new materials.
  5. Less sustainable: Replacing a fence may not be the most sustainable option, as it involves using new materials rather than repairing and reusing the existing fence.

Ultimately, the decision to repair or replace a damaged fence depends on several factors, including the extent of the damage, the age of the fence, the cost of repair versus replacement, and your personal preferences. It’s important to weigh the pros and cons of each option before making a decision. If you’re unsure, consult with a professional fence contractor who can assess the damage and provide a recommendation based on your specific situation.